Skip to content
Setup Journal
Honest comparison · checked 18 November 2026

Setup Journal vs TradeZella

TradeZella is a great, full-featured journal. It is also $35 to $99 a month. Here is what you get and what you give up with each, including the things we don't do.

Pick Setup Journal if
  • You trade futures or forex on Tradovate, NinjaTrader or MetaTrader
  • You buy prop firm evals and want to know your real ROI on fees
  • You copy trades across several accounts
  • You want a small accountability group without P&L bragging
  • You don't want to pay every month to look at your own trades
Pick TradeZella if
  • You trade stocks, options or crypto
  • You want trades to sync from your broker with no export step
  • You want backtesting or trade replay in the same tool
  • You want an AI to answer questions about your trading
  • You want live prop firm rule and drawdown monitoring
Side by side

Feature by feature

Yes, partly, no, or not advertised on their public site.

Price
What it costs Setup Journal: Yes. Free forever. Every feature, sync and 1 GB of screenshots. TradeZella: . Essential $35, Pro $59, Ultra $99 a month ($26, $44, $74 a month billed yearly).
Accounts Setup Journal: Yes. Unlimited. TradeZella: Partly. 1 on Essential, up to 50 on Pro, unlimited on Ultra.
Getting trades in
Broker connection Setup Journal: Partly. No live connection. You export a CSV and drop it in. We never ask for a broker login. TradeZella: Yes. Automatic sync with 500+ brokers and prop firms, plus file upload and manual entry.
Markets Setup Journal: Partly. Futures and forex only. TradeZella: Yes. Stocks, options, forex, crypto, and futures on select exchanges.
Fees and P&L accuracy Setup Journal: Yes. Exchange, clearing and NFA fees from Tradovate Cash History, checked against your balance. TradeZella: Yes. Commissions and fees tracking on all plans.
Screenshots Setup Journal: Yes. Drop a folder. Each screenshot is matched to its trade by the time in its filename. TradeZella: Partly. Screenshots, notes and voice memos on trades.
Review and improvement
Daily review Setup Journal: Yes. Review inbox and three-tap Quick review. Journal page per day with slash commands. TradeZella: Yes. Daily journal, notes and auto-tagging (agents on Pro and up).
Reports Setup Journal: Partly. Focused: dashboard, calendar, setups and mistakes, weekly recap. No custom report builder. TradeZella: Yes. 50+ reports.
Playbooks and rules Setup Journal: Partly. Setups and mistakes priced in dollars, daily trade limit, pre-market checklist template. TradeZella: Yes. Playbooks with rule tracking per strategy.
Habits Setup Journal: Yes. Trading right after a loss, sizing up after a loss and going past your daily limit are spotted from your fills. TradeZella: Yes. Habit and risk management AI agents (Pro and up).
AI coach Setup Journal: No. None. The weekly recap is plain rules, not AI. TradeZella: Yes. Zella AI: ask questions about your trades (500 to 3,000 credits a month).
Backtesting Setup Journal: No. None. TradeZella: Yes. Bar-by-bar and AI backtesting.
Trade replay Setup Journal: No. None. You see your own chart screenshots. TradeZella: Yes. Replay with synced fills (Pro and up).
Missed trades Setup Journal: Yes. Log setups you skipped and see if hesitating costs you. TradeZella: . Not advertised.
Prop firms and multiple accounts
Prop firm money Setup Journal: Yes. Prop firm ROI: every eval, reset, activation fee and payout, ROI by firm, pass rate, dry spells. TradeZella: Partly. Prop Firm Sync: live rule monitoring and pass-rate forecasting for 15+ firms. We did not find a fees-versus-payouts ROI ledger.
Prop rules and drawdown alerts Setup Journal: No. Not yet. We don't store each firm's rules. TradeZella: Yes. Real-time rule monitoring.
Copy trades Setup Journal: Yes. Copies across accounts within 10 seconds are one trade, money summed. TradeZella: . Not advertised.
Community and privacy
Groups Setup Journal: Yes. Pods of up to 6 traders: weekly process numbers, never dollars, plus each person's commitment. TradeZella: Yes. Spaces: invite-only rooms, live trade sharing, group challenges and leaderboards.
Mentors and friends Setup Journal: Yes. Per-person access (stats, trades or everything), comments, ask for a review. TradeZella: Yes. Mentor mode.
Learning Setup Journal: Partly. Guides and a blog. TradeZella: Yes. Zella University, webinars and bootcamps.
Offline Setup Journal: Yes. Works with no internet and syncs later. Installable like an app. TradeZella: . Not advertised.
Notion Setup Journal: Yes. Optional one-way copy of your journal into Notion. TradeZella: . Not advertised.

TradeZella details come from tradezella.com and its pricing page on 18 November 2026. TradeZella is a trademark of its owner. Setup Journal is not affiliated with TradeZella.

Only in Setup Journal

The parts we built that others don't

Prop firm ROI

Every dollar of eval fees against every payout

Most prop traders know their payout total but not what they spent to get it. Log each eval and payout and you get one honest number, by firm.

For prop firm traders
Prop firm ROI page
A pod's weekly check-in
Pods

Accountability without the P&L show-off

Up to six traders see each other's week as process numbers and the one thing each promised to fix. Dollar amounts are never shown, so nobody performs for the group.

For trading groups

Questions, answered

Is Setup Journal really free, or is there a paid tier coming?

Free forever. The app does its work in your browser, so it costs very little to run. There is no paid tier and no feature held back.

Can I move from TradeZella to Setup Journal?

Yes, if you trade futures or forex. Export your history from your platform (Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8 or MetaTrader) rather than from TradeZella, and drop it in. See the import guide.

Why doesn't Setup Journal connect to my broker automatically?

Two reasons: we never want your broker login, and file imports give exact fees and stops that many live connections miss. The cost is one export after each session.

Where did you get TradeZella's details?

From tradezella.com and tradezella.com/pricing on 18 November 2026. Prices and features change; if something here is out of date, email hello@setupjournal.com and we'll fix it.

See it with sample data first

No account needed to look around. Every feature is free when you're ready to import.