Setup Journal vs TradeZella
TradeZella is a great, full-featured journal. It is also $35 to $99 a month. Here is what you get and what you give up with each, including the things we don't do.
- You trade futures or forex on Tradovate, NinjaTrader or MetaTrader
- You buy prop firm evals and want to know your real ROI on fees
- You copy trades across several accounts
- You want a small accountability group without P&L bragging
- You don't want to pay every month to look at your own trades
- You trade stocks, options or crypto
- You want trades to sync from your broker with no export step
- You want backtesting or trade replay in the same tool
- You want an AI to answer questions about your trading
- You want live prop firm rule and drawdown monitoring
Feature by feature
Yes, partly, no, or not advertised on their public site.
TradeZella details come from tradezella.com and its pricing page on 18 November 2026. TradeZella is a trademark of its owner. Setup Journal is not affiliated with TradeZella.
The parts we built that others don't
Every dollar of eval fees against every payout
Most prop traders know their payout total but not what they spent to get it. Log each eval and payout and you get one honest number, by firm.
For prop firm traders
Accountability without the P&L show-off
Up to six traders see each other's week as process numbers and the one thing each promised to fix. Dollar amounts are never shown, so nobody performs for the group.
For trading groupsQuestions, answered
Is Setup Journal really free, or is there a paid tier coming?
Free forever. The app does its work in your browser, so it costs very little to run. There is no paid tier and no feature held back.
Can I move from TradeZella to Setup Journal?
Yes, if you trade futures or forex. Export your history from your platform (Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8 or MetaTrader) rather than from TradeZella, and drop it in. See the import guide.
Why doesn't Setup Journal connect to my broker automatically?
Two reasons: we never want your broker login, and file imports give exact fees and stops that many live connections miss. The cost is one export after each session.
Where did you get TradeZella's details?
From tradezella.com and tradezella.com/pricing on 18 November 2026. Prices and features change; if something here is out of date, email hello@setupjournal.com and we'll fix it.
See it with sample data first
No account needed to look around. Every feature is free when you're ready to import.